James Trafford: Has Leeds goalkeeper overtaken Jordan Pickford as England's No 1 after starring display against Spain?
Do England have a new No 1? Thomas Tuchel insists not. "There's no No 1," he said. But Jordan Pickford might have his work cut out to wrestle the shirt back from James Trafford on the evidence of his performance in England's 3-2 win over Spain.
It felt significant that he started in the first place. Pickford has been England's undisputed first choice for a decade; an outstanding servant to the national team whose total of 94 caps puts him behind only Peter Shilton among the most-capped goalkeepers.
But this was undoubtedly England's biggest test of their Nations League campaign and Tuchel opted for Trafford, encouraged by his displays at home to Spain and away to Czech Republic in September. "He had a brilliant match," he added afterwards.
If it is a changing of the guard, then it is being handled carefully. "I think it's smart management," said Sky Sports' Roy Keane before kick-off in Madrid. "This is the perfect time for Trafford to come in, against top players, and show what he's capable of doing."
Trafford had little to do up until Elliot Anderson's sending-off in the 63rd minute. Spain had not even registered a shot on target at that point. The 24-year-old's only duties were occasional goal kicks and passes as the hosts struggled to get close to his goal.
But it all changed when Anderson departed. Suddenly, Trafford had to contend with swarming red shirts and a flurry of shots.
His focus didn't waver. His biggest contribution was his double save in stoppage time, when he dived to his right to deny Fermin Lopez then instantly pushed Mikel Oyarzabal's follow-up around the post.
"Every time you watch goalkeepers doing drills, it's that, making the save and then the reaction," said Keane, marvelling at the speed of his reflexes. Trafford was mobbed by team-mates afterwards.
But he had already kept Spain at bay on several occasions before that. In the 74th minute, he denied Lopez following a corner. He could do little about Spain's second goal, scored at close-range by Nico Williams from Lamine Yamal's perfect centre.
But Trafford was alert to save from Lamine Yamal shortly after that. He then got to his feet, in similar style to his double save in stoppage time, to prevent Marc Cucurella's angled shot from creeping in.
"Very good," added Tuchel in his press conference. "That's his job, to close the gap. We want competition in all positions."
"We need to see Trafford in high-pressure moments.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
"The obvious save, where he deserves full credit, is the double save at the very end. Absolutely brilliant."
But the England boss also highlighted the importance of his composure in possession. "There was a lot to do in the deep build-up as well, which he did very, very well, with everyone around him.
"Never lose the concentration, never lose the focus, never lose the vision where to find the free men to overcome the press and put the game to the opponent's half.
"With everyone else, he was part of a fantastic team performance."
Trafford's ball-playing ability was moulded in Manchester City's academy and with England's youth sides. His saves, meanwhile, were a continuation of his club performances this season.
According to underlying data from Opta, Trafford ranks top among all Premier League goalkeepers for goals prevented this season, having only conceded eight times for Leeds from shots worth 12.40 expected goals, giving him a score of 4.40.
It should be noted that Pickford also has a positive differential, having conceded 10 goals from shots worth 11.05 expected goals. He is eight years older than Trafford, at 32, but clearly has plenty left to offer. "There's not much between them," said Keane.
Pickford has an obvious advantage in terms of experience.
In addition to have 94 senior caps to Trafford's five, he has 372 Premier League appearances behind him. But a comparison of their numbers shows similar figures for percentage of shots saved.
Their styles differ in terms of their distribution, with Trafford sending a lower percentage of passes long, although that is partly explained by the differences in the way their respective clubs play.
For Tuchel, Trafford's impact can only be positive. He insisted there is no first-choice. But that in itself shows the dynamic has changed. Trafford looks ready for more opportunities - and having thwarted the world champions, they might come sooner rather than later.
Play Super 6 for a chance to win £1m! Enter for free.
- Last
News by day
16 of November 2026