The All-Stars who are halfway to history in 2025

16.07.2025, 03:43 espn.com

This year, the MLB All-Star Game isn't just a collection of the game's biggest stars, but a glimpse at baseball history in the making.

The 2025 Midsummer Classic marks the unofficial midway point of some of the greatest seasons the sport has ever seen.

Will Home Run Derby champion Cal Raleigh -- aka the Big Dumper -- set a new standard for slugging catchers? Will Shohei Ohtani score more runs in a season than any living person has ever seen? Will Aaron Judge ... top Aaron Judge?

As the best from the major leagues convene in Atlanta, Bradford Doolittle and David Schoenfield break down 11 players who are halfway to history. For each, ESPN MLB reporters Jorge Castillo and Jesse Rogers asked one of the player's fellow All-Stars to weigh in on his accomplishments, as they all get set to take the field together at Truist Park.

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Well, we can add Home Run Derby champion to the list after Raleigh's impressive showing Monday night. With 38 home runs through 96 team games, Raleigh is on pace for 64, which would break Judge's American League record of 62 set in 2022. That's the big one. There are a whole bunch of other records in play: most home runs by a switch-hitter (Mickey Mantle, 54); most home runs by a primary catcher (Salvador Perez, 48); most multihomer games in a season (Raleigh has eight, the record is 11); and even highest catcher WAR in a season (Mike Piazza with 8.7 bWAR, Raleigh is on pace for 8.4; Buster Posey with 9.8 fWAR, Raleigh is on pace for 10.4). In other words, he could have the greatest season ever for a catcher.

"The Big Dumper" has been the Northwest's secret star. Now he's hitting the big time. Jeff Passan »

How he's doing it: Raleigh has always been better against right-handed pitching, but he has been absolutely crushing lefties in 2025, hitting .337/.385/.861 with 16 home runs in only 101 at-bats. Overall, he also has been much better against velocity. From 2022 to 2024, he slugged .418 against pitches 93 mph or faster; this year, he's slugging .664. -- Schoenfield

An All-Star's take: "It's wild. I mean, he's having a crazy year and it's awesome that he's doing it from behind the plate. And what he's doing is unbelievable. It's hard to describe. It's amazing to see." -- Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Judge closed out the first half with a quiet day against the Chicago Cubs but is still on pace to record 435 total bases this season. You could pick any one of a dozen categories in which Judge is on a historic pace, but this simple old-school measure will do just fine. The record is held by Babe Ruth (457 in 1921), so Judge would have to somehow pick up the pace to surpass that. But 435 would still be epic. The last player to reach that number was Jimmie Foxx in 1932.

Frequent IL trips early in his career "pissed him off." Now, Aaron Judge is playing every day -- and setting new standards. Jorge Castillo »

How he's doing it: Judge has become more aggressive at the plate without sacrificing contact or power. But it's not only ball-in-play volume; he's hitting an incredible .425 when getting the bat on the ball, which fuels his MLB-leading .355 batting average. That BABIP would be the third-highest ever if Judge maintained it, which obviously affects the total bases column. So too does Judge's intentional walks pace (41). He'd be only the fourth player to top 40. -- Doolittle

An All-Star's take: "He started off hot this year, which normally in years past, he doesn't start off hot like he did this year. And now you see it. He always finishes strong. I mean, I don't know what he ends up with. Hopefully he hits like 70 homers. That'd be sick." -- New York Yankees left-hander Carlos Rodon

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Although his pace has slowed a bit the past couple of weeks, Ohtani has scored 89 runs in 94 games, giving him a chance at a run scored per game. Ohtani had been on pace for 160 runs, which only Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig have done since 1900. He's still on pace for 150 runs, which only Ted Williams and Jeff Bagwell have done since World War II. The last player with more runs scored than games played, with at least 100 games played: Rickey Henderson in 1985 (146 runs in 143 games). If that's not enough to impress you, there is the chance for a second straight 50-homer season and a fourth career MVP award. If the latter happens, he'll join Barry Bonds as the only player with more than three MVP awards.

How he's doing it: It helps to be a leadoff man with power, as Ohtani leads the National League in both plate appearances and home runs. The first three months, Ohtani also had a great trio hitting behind him in Mookie Betts, Freddie Freeman and Will Smith, but his runs scored pace has dropped off in July as he has hit just .175, and Betts and Freeman have also slumped. -- Schoenfield

An All-Star's take: "As his teammate and fellow competitor, to see what he does on both sides of the field, it's incredible. How much power he has as a hitter. He's got 30-plus homers already at the break. He's hitting .300 or whatever. And, yeah, he's going out there on the mound and throwing 102, striking out the side. And these are his rehab games. He's not even all the way back yet, full-go yet. It's incredible to watch. Fortunately, I get to see all the work he puts in every day, which is really cool. It's really special what he's doing." -- Los Angeles Dodgers catcher Will Smith

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Skenes' ERA at the break is an NL-best 2.01. His career mark is 1.98 over 43 starts. There is all kinds of history around this level of stifling run prevention. As it stands, Skenes joins Ed Walsh, Addie Joss and Mordecai "Three Finger" Brown with at least 40 starts and a sub-2.00 career ERA in the AL or NL. If Skenes drops his 2025 number below 2.00, he'd be the 31st pitcher to have two or more sub-2.00 ERA seasons of at least 20 starts. Only two of those pitchers did it by age 23: Walter Johnson and Ed Reulbach, both more than 100 years ago.

Amid the noise that comes with arriving as MLB's next megastar, the Pirates' ace is finding himself in the quiet. Jeff Passan »

How he's doing it: Skenes' strikeout rate (9.7 per nine innings) is down 1.8 from last year. Yet his FIP (an NL-best 2.41) is actually better because of his league-best homer rate (0.4 per nine innings). Simply put, Skenes is learning how to manage the pure dominance of his arsenal, revving it up when needed. Skenes is not exactly pitching to contact -- his stuff is just too good to not miss a lot of bats -- but his pitch efficiency is better, and that's getting him deeper into games. His style has evolved, but one big thing has remained steady: Nobody can score off him. -- Doolittle

An All-Star's take: "Obviously, the first thing that stands out is his stuff, right? And the second thing you look at is the composure. He's kind of new to the league and just from watching some of his preparation, his composure on the mound, I feel like that's what makes him successful. He started to add a couple of new pitches to his arsenal and it's going to make him tougher. He's got the military background, so I think that's where he gets a lot of his discipline and everything from. He's challenging, but it is fun to compete against him." -- St. Louis Cardinals infielder Brendan Donovan

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Skubal has struck out 9.56 batters for every one he has walked. Only four qualifying pitchers have ever done better: Phil Hughes (11.63, 2014), Bret Saberhagen (11.00, 1994), Cliff Lee (10.28, 2010) and Curt Schilling (9.58, 2002). The leaderboard is dominated by wild-card era pitchers, with its heightened whiff rates. But according to FanGraphs' plus-statistics, which compare numbers to league averages, Skubal's index of 368 ranks 18th all time. His mastery works in any era.

"I wasn't good until I was 26," the All-Star pitcher says. Here's how Skubal rose from Little League lore to Cy Young. Tim Keown »

How he's doing it: Skubal has already had two games this season in which he has struck out 13 batters on fewer than 100 pitches. Simply put, his command keeps him in the zone more than any qualifying pitcher (49.7%, per FanGraphs). But it also allows him to pitch outside of it on his terms. To wit: Skubal also leads the majors in inducing swings on pitches out of the zone (37.2%). It's a lethal combination. -- Doolittle

An All-Star's take: "Even on game days, he's working before the game like he's not pitching that day. Even on the off days, he's at the field doing something. He does a whole routine. I faced him in spring training and was looking for one pitch -- when that pitch came, I didn't hit it. He knows what hitters are looking for." -- Detroit Tigers outfielder Javier Baez

The most impressive thing he could accomplish: Before the 2023 season, there had been only four 40-homer/40-steal seasons in big league history, and the 40/50 club was memberless. Now Crow-Armstrong is on a 42-homer, 46-steal pace at the break. He could join Ronald Acuna Jr. (41 homers, 73 steals in 2023) and Shohei Ohtani (54 homers, 59 steals last season) in one or both clubs, giving us a three-year run of expanding membership. This one would be the most stunning of all. PCA entered the season with 10 homers, 29 steals and an 83 OPS+ in his career. His rise has been flat-out stunning.

Inside the rise of Pete Crow-Armstrong, MLB's next superstar. Jesse Rogers »

How he's doing it: The steals part of Crow-Armstrong's game was already there, though he's picked up the pace in 2025, already matching his 27 steals from last season. Any time he reaches safely, he's a threat to take an extra base. That is unless he's trotting around the bags after mashing yet another homer. Crow-Armstrong is hitting the ball harder more often, getting more balls in the air and pulling it more frequently. All of this could explain an i