Our website uses cookies to provide your browsing experience and relevant information. Before continuing to use our website, you agree & accept our Cookie Policy & Privacy.
Purchasing a new eyeliner pencil (and tbh, figuring out how to use it like a pro) can feel like an impossible task, especially when virtually every makeup brand offers an eyeliner pencil in their lineup. What’s the best liner that won’t skip or drag?! Which one won’t smudge after an hour?! Should I go for pricier option or choose a drugstore eyeliner?! Do I need a gel formula or a creamy one?! Should I buy a colorful eyeliner or a classic black one?! So many questions, so many options, so little mental space to figure it all out. So to makes things easier for ya, I researched and tested a ton of different eyeliner pencils to bring you this list of the top 12.
